Deficit
-Robin
Lackoff (1975)
-women use many techniques in their speech that are
deficient to men's speech. These include:
- fillers
- hedges
- intensifiers
- hyper-correct grammar
- tag questions
- super-polite forms
- apologise more
- speak less frequently
- avoid coarse language or expletives
- indirect requests
- speak in italics
-Jenny
Cheshire (1982)
-Boys use
more non-standard forms than girls.
-Pamela Fishman (1983)
-Tag questions- Lackoff claimed they represent uncertainty, Fishman says
they are used to initiate conversation
-She refers to setting the agenda as the 'conversational shitwork'
and says men are reluctant to do this as they perceive to be the dominant
role
Dominance
-Zimmerman & West (1975)
-men dominate a conversation by using more
interruptions
-Deborah Cameron (1995)
-challenges views, says that
women do in fact challenge each other
Difference
-Deborah Tannen (1990)
-Men and women speak very differently in
conversation, six contrasts to show this difference:
- Status vs. support
- independence vs. intimacy
- advice vs. understanding
- information vs. feelings
- orders vs. proposals
- conflict vs. compromise
-Janet Hyde (2005)
-proposed a 'gender similarities
hypothesis'
-"substantially more
similarities than differences...and where there are differences, they are due
to other contextual factors for example education, occupation etc."
-argument